- in Books , Into The World , Mindset
- 6 comments
What do Yoga, the Law of Attraction and A Course in Miracles have in common?
What do yoga, the Law of Attraction and A Course in Miracles have in common? A few things, but on critical points, they directly contradict one another. This could potentially confuse the modern spiritual seeker, delaying peace.
This century is a veritable buffet of spirituality, and with so many dishes to choose from, it’s easy to overindulge and end up feeling sick.
Making it more confusing, many high-profile spiritual leaders and yoga teachers mix philosophies without clarifying the source of a belief or statement. For those wanting to follow the yogi path, this could cause a great deal of confusion.
What is the Law of Attraction?
The Law of Attraction was popularized by the book The Secret. It basically says that you can manifest anything you desire by thinking positively and changing your vibration.
Thoughts are essentially electromagnetic waves. The Secret says that if you change the vibration of your thoughts to match that of your desired reality, that future will have no choice but to materialize. Similar vibrations will naturally attract one another, this philosophy says.
This sounds wonderful, but I believe the Law of Attraction actually prevents us from enjoying our natural state of joy. It focuses a lot on what you want to happen instead of cultivating gratitude for what is and surrendering your will to Divine will.
How does yoga differ from the Law of Attraction?
There’s a very dangerous undercurrent in the Law of Attraction that involves blaming ourselves for bad things that happen to us.
Get cancer? It’s probably your fault because you were thinking bad thoughts or you’re low-vibe. Lose your luggage? You probably made it happen somehow.
While our external realities do have a lot to do with what emanates from within, some people, in my opinion, take it too far. We don’t have control over our lives. Only immense influence.
This is really different from the system of yoga, which first of all operates on a much longer timeline. The Law of Attraction posits that we can manifest things in a timeframe of several months or years. Ancient yogis believe in reincarnation, and so the timelines of karma — which is nothing more than action and reaction — span centuries and multiple lifetimes.
I’ve sometimes seen karma referenced as the basis for the Law of Attraction, but karma in the purest sense says that every action causes a reaction.
In yoga, we are not punished, only taught. So if we kill someone in a previous life, then maybe in our next life we experience the consequences so that our soul can evolve. Either way, only a person who suffers causes the suffering of others and sometimes that is punishment enough.
Yogis also believe that we don’t know the larger picture. Perhaps one tragedy prevented an even more horrific one from happening.
Another way these two philosophies differ is the idea of influencing outcomes. While in the Law of Attraction, people are encouraged to set clear goals and consistently visualize their lives as if the wishes were already true, yoga teaches us to take positive action without attaching to results.
Yogis cultivate trust in the universe’s grand plan, letting go of control and surrendering to the flow of life. Yoga teaches that we don’t have control, only power over our actions and responses. Meanwhile, the Law of Attraction emphasizes generating the outcome that we wish, which often leaves us blaming ourselves if things don’t work out as intended.
Trying to live by yogic principles and the Law of Attraction could cause suffering and feelings of conflict.
Another critical component of the yogi’s path is living in the moment. Mindfulness brings peace. Yet the Law of Attraction encourages us to pay precious attention to our desires that don’t exist right now when we could spend time just being grateful for what we already have.
This focus on manifesting can engender feelings of ungratefulness and jealousy as we see others experiencing the life we want, but don’t have. We may believe we’re doing something wrong, or worse, that there’s something wrong with us because our similar dreams aren’t coming true.
Another point of difference is in the way painful emotions are handled. In the Law of Attraction, people often feel afraid of sadness and anger because of worries these feelings will bring undesirable circumstances or even lead to disease.
Note: The more I learn about the Law of Attraction, the more I see that experts do talk about feeling your feelings, but it’s still very much with the intention to “get rid” of them, or with the undercurrent that if you feel sad or “low vibe,” good things won’t happen to you.
In the effort to stay high-vibe at all costs, we may ignore inner turmoil that could be a catalyst for a powerful transformation.
And so we may bury these feelings, sugarcoating and pretending everything is dandy instead of honestly confronting and feeling painful emotions.
In yoga, we feel emotions and have compassion for ourselves, not reacting to how we feel, but instead sitting with it until pain dissipates into peace and clarity. We investigate these feelings because we recognize that they hold lessons.
In yoga, cultivating presence and compassion guides us toward true, unshakeable peace. We develop this by going through the fire of pain, not by ignoring it and hoping it goes away.
Both philosophies promote the idea that a good life comes from cultivating positive thoughts and a cheerful disposition. That’s the main similarity.
What is a Course in Miracles?
A Course in Miracles has also generated much buzz and is espoused by popular self-help gurus like Gabrielle Bernstein, who also teaches Kundalini yoga to make matters even more confusing, and Marianne Williamson, who wrote A Return to Love, which is possibly even more famous than the original Course.
A Course in Miracles generally encourages love over fear. While yoga also encourages love, A Course in Miracles is based in Christianity and so the tones are different. It characterizes spiritual evolution as a battle between fear and love. By choosing love and forgiveness, we silence the ego and its fear, which seeks to destroy us.
Yoga also talks about clouded sight that has the power to cause emotional pain, but yoga teaches accepting all parts of ourselves with compassion, and to go through what we’re feeling because it all has meaning. We find peace by processing pain, by sitting with whatever is.
In yoga, we don’t really battle against things, but instead cultivate trust and the habit of no fear through surrender and acceptance.
Here is a prime example of the difference between A Course in Miracles and yoga. In A Return to Love, Williamson writes:
“Only love is real. Nothing else actually exists. If a person behaves unlovingly, than, that means that, regardless of their negativity — anger or whatever — their behavior was derived from fear and doesn’t actually exist. They’re hallucinating. You forgive them, then, because there’s nothing to forgive. Forgiveness is a discernment between what is real and what is not real.”
By contrast, in the classic tome The Heart of Yoga, T. K. V. Desikachar writes:
“If we subscribe to yogic concepts, then everything that we see, experience, and feel is not illusion; it is true and real.”
Yoga — the path toward peace
In yoga, we better our lives and selves through presence, by practicing the art of discernment, ridding the mind of the stories we tell ourselves so we can see clearly and make good choices. Accepting what is so we can be happy in the present moment.
Ultimately, we rid our hearts of desire, which causes pain. One definition of yoga is to join our will to the will of God, or the universe. We see that we’re just one piece of a puzzle and surrender what’s best for us to instead promote what’s best for the greater good.
Yoga says we go about our lives, doing the best we can, but we can never be sure what the result will be of our actions. So we do the best we can and let go of the outcome. We let go of expectation and focus on what’s happening right now, trusting that whatever is happening is the will of the Divine.
Once we’re firmly anchored in the peace of our own heart, the turmoil of another cannot disturb us. We only react to what already exists inside ourselves.
In a state of total surrender the mind and heart see clearly. Then, we feel joyful and at peace.
Do you mix these philosophies? What is your experience?
*Some of the links in this article are affiliate links, and I will receive a small percentage of the sale if you purchase through them, at no cost to you. Thank you for your support!
I absolutely mix these beliefs.
Living in the moment and trusting life is a big part of my daily mindset in order to keep my mind from going haywire anxious and it works quite well. Being very goal oriented with daily task, not marking everything off the list can put me in a not so good place mentally. Having a adopted more the yogi mindset through a daily practice, I’ll find myself often saying if you run out of lavender soap (I’m a soap maker) big deal, the world will still turn and it does.
After watching “The Secret” many years ago living in MO, utterly tired of winter and dreaming of a different life, I gave LOA a try. Making a folder on my computer of what the house we would we live may look like, what the view would be etc. I opened this folder every single morning upon waking coupled with naming at least one thing that I was grateful for in my life at that moment, something I still do today. My yoga and meditation practice continued but I also took action by saving $20 from each job (I was a photographer at the time). Over the course of a year, I had enough in my coat pocket to afford a trip for my husband and I to California, my dream destination, to check things out.
The story gets really interesting but in an effort to keep it short, it ended with us living in CA about 1.5 years later from starting my LOA folder. When I look back at the folder, it’s almost unreal how things matched up to the images in my folder.
I’ll end with I’m not big on using LOA for material things, but more for goals. On the other hand, I practice yoga daily and have learned to go with my flow, enjoy the breeze hitting my face in that moment, the flowers and veggies in our yard and just being present. This I believe is called balance and for me it works. It’s not one thing or the other, but a combination of efforts and non-efforts.
We can’t control everything nor do I think we should guide our lives like a ship. It is healthy to have direction but equally as important to be flexible as things can change. When we moved to CA, I wanted to be a fashion photographer in LA after shooting for eight years in MO. We had a house fire that caused an extreme amount of struggle that completely changed my course. I no longer wanted to struggle running to LA to shoot for free in hopes that one day I would be discovered, it lost its appeal. At that point, I had to trust life and I let go. It was a Rosemary face mist that me made smile on the 100 degree days living in a tent during the fire times that sparked an interest in wanting to know how to make lotion next to ease my dry skin. To make lotion, a soap making class was required so I signed up. I found a great love in essential oils and making soap and now have moved onto beginning lotion and the start of a successful company.
My yogi mind allowed me to let go and go with the flow of life and now a little LOA will help me reach some goals.
What an awesome story Marcie! Thank you so much for sharing! That is so beautiful. I’m so happy envisioning your life as you wanted it helped you realize that life! Maybe there is something to this LOA, at least when it’s backed with action. I can see how feeding the mind images of your ideal life could definitely help a person make positive steps in that direction. I also really like how you mention ending the visualization settings with gratitude. I do have a vision board and find it very helpful to center myself with the images, especially when I’m confused or in fear mode. Looking at the board helps me remember my goals when I was in a place of love and full of hope. Thank you so much for sharing your story!
Thru the years, I have found the same wonderful living, l balance for myself with the needs of growth as I live my life. I am 65 yrs old now and I am open to listening to others with love.
Great post! The biggest misconception about the law of attraction is people just think all you need to do is visualize and you will get what you want,we all have limiting beliefs that’s like being a chain holding us back from manifesting what we want,we’ve gotten these limiting beliefs when we were young from our parents,friends,relatives ,e.g if you’ve always been told by your parents “money doesnt grow on trees” and that becomes a deep rooted limiting belief ,its going to be hard to visualize and attract money into your life unless you get rid of the limiting beliefs, and i’ve been using this method that gets rid of any limiting beliefs that you may have and start attracting whatever you want here: http://subconciousmindzone.com/2015/06/15/subconscious-mind-tools/
[…] What do yoga, the Law of Attraction and A Course in Miracles have in common? A few things, but on critical points, they directly contradict one another, potentially leaving the modern spiritual se… […]
There is so much more to A Course in Miracles than the tiny excerpt that you’ve inserted to sum up Marianne W’s book. It actually isn’t based on Christianity as the common Christian understands it at all. Far from it! A Course in Miracles talks about how we are far more than our bodies, and that the whole of creation is one mind. Our bodies make humans think that we are separate entities from each other, when in fact we are not. When we are focused on our bodies, we are actually focused on our egos. Our egos have led us to believe that we must attack others and protect what we think is valuable, when in fact the ego has no idea what is valuable because it is insane. We chase after all of the ideals that the ego has led us to think are valuable (which never give us satisfaction), thus we are also chasing after insanity.
The main aim of A Course in Miracles is to teach us how to have peace. In A Course in Miracles, there are 365 lessons that help us to undo the teachings of the ego, which remove the barrier that makes us think that we are separate from God and each other. We are not separate from God, and we are not separate from each other. The ego only makes us think that we are. Think of the waves in the ocean… infinite in number, strong, powerful, beautiful. The waves are not separate from the ocean, yet they appear to be individual. Every single living creation on the earth is a wave and God is the ocean. There is no separating us from each other (although we appear to have individual bodies), and there is no separating us from God. We all come from the same source and we are made of what our source is made of. None of this has changed even though we appear to walk this earth as what appears to be individual human beings. This is what A Course in Miracles teaches. Actually, this is just the tip of the iceberg.